Although I already described the official procedures that religiously observant Jews follow in order to express gratitude for their food, I have not addressed my personal experience with these prayers and rituals. I attended a Jewish summer camp as a child; it was a sports camp when my older cousins and sister attended, but due to financial difficulties (and the fact that the majority of campers happened to be Jewish anyway) it became affiliated with the UAHC, a Reform Jewish organization. Due to this transition, we started to say "grace" before and after our meals. We began each meal with a communal Ha-Motzi and ended with an abbreviated version of the Birkat Hamazon. We sang the prayers as a group and added our own flares like keeping a beat by slapping the table and saying "pass the pepto bismol" under out breath at the same time. I loved the sing-song nature of these prayers, but I did not consciously connect them to appreciation for my meal until I went to college.
My first Shabbat dinner at Brown RISD Hillel began with the hand washing ritual, which I had never seen before. People filled the two handled cup with water, poured it over their hands, and mumbled some Hebrew prayer under their breath. Following suit, I filled a cup, poured it over my hands, and mumbled the standard beginning to blessings, "Baruch atah Adonai, Eloheinu Melech ha-olam..." and then I pretended to know the end of the prayer by moving my mouth but not saying any words. I dried my hands on a towel and sat down silently at a table before someone else said Ha-Motzi. I ate my piece of challah and started the meal. This experience was not too discomforting, but when the end of the meal came, I was utterly lost. Everyone gathered around, took out benchers (the book with Shabbat songs and meal-time prayers) and began the Ha-Motzi. I started with them, but I quickly realized that they did not sing my abbreviated version; in fact, theirs was about ten minutes long. It took me weeks of practice to even follow along, let alone sing. In fact, just this past winter break I downloaded an MP3 file of someone singing this prayer, borrowed a bencher from Hillel, and learned to say the entire prayer from start to end.
While learning how to say prayers was stressful, the unfamiliar nature of the words enticed me to actually read and reflect on what I was saying. Some paragraphs focused on giving thanks for the actual food that had been eaten, others talked about the exodus from Egypt, still others were about the destruction of the Temple. This made me think about how my eating was connected to generations of Jewish people who came before me. I was reciting the same words that people hundreds of years ago said. Furthermore, the long prayer, which once felt tedious, made me realize how I do not spend much time thinking about my food. All of that would change when I started keeping kosher, but the prayers themselves allowed me to consider how lucky I was to have food on my plate and how food consumption deserves more of my attention. Although I did not connect this thankfulness to food production until later, when I started my kosher quest, I came to understand the importance of prayer in relation to food.
Kosher @ Kollege
Thursday, February 23, 2012
Tuesday, February 21, 2012
Giving Thanks: An Introduction
While the laws of kashrut govern food production and consumption, other Jewish ritual practices exist that focus on mankind's appreciation of food. Observant Jews thank G-d at the beginning and end of each meal. There is actually a whole set of behaviors that are performed at the beginning and end of each meal.
On Shabbat, a family makes kiddush, or the blessing over the wine together. This prayer, in transliteration reads "Baruch atah Adonai Eloheinu melech ha-olam, borei p'ri hagafen," and in translation "Praised are you, the Lord our G-d, Sovereign of the universe, who creates the fruit of the vine" (B'kol Echad 9). The wine is then distributed among those at the table, often including a bit for the children or substituted with grape juice, and consumed. Although this practice does not occur every day of the week, it demonstrates an appreciation for this particular food. This practice also draws a loose connection between Judaism and Christianity, both of which have a special ceremonial place for wine, and reveals that alcohol is not only allowed in Judaism, but it an integral part of certain rituals.
The next sets of rituals apply on Shabbat and weekdays, with minor additions or alterations on Shabbat and other holidays.
Before one recites any (more) brachot, or prayers, they wash their hands. This washing is not the soap-and-water cleaning that my parents always instructed me to do before sitting down at the table, but a ritual washing called netilat yadayim involving a special cup with two handles. One fills the cup with water, holds the handles, and splashes water on his or her hands, traditionally with two splashes on the right hand and then two on the left. I generally put in another on each afterward for good measure, although I have no logical reason for doing so, I am simply forming my own style as I adopt this new practice. After wetting one's hands, a person recites "Baruch atah Adonai Eloheinu melech ha-olam, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav, v'tzivanu al n'tilat yadayim," meaning, "Praised are you, Lord our G-d, Sovereign of the universe, who has sanctified us with G-d's commandments and had commanded us to wash our hands" (B'kol Echad 19). One can then dry his or her hands, but must remain silent between this washing and taking the first bite of challah bread.
Next, a prayer is said over the bread called Ha-Motzi. Although one is supposed to be silent after washing, he or she can break this silence in order to make the bracha (singular of blessing) over the bread. Traditionally, two loaves of challah, the braided bread that women are commanded to make (and burn a piece of) for Shabbat, are lifted and someone says "Baruch atah Adonai, Eloheinu melech ha-olam, hamotzi lechem min ha-aretz," meaning, "Praised are You, Lord and G-d, Sovereign of the universe, who brings forth bread from the earth" (B'kol Echad 20). Those at the table then salt the bread in commemoration of the destruction of the Temple, break off a piece of bread, eat it themselves, and pass the loaf along to the next person. Then, the meal can proceed.
Finally, at the end of the meal, those who have dined recite Birkat Ha-Mazon, a prayer giving thanks to G-d for the food that was consumed, as well as giving thanks to G-d for the Torah and its teachings, exodus from Egypt, the land of Zion, and more. The prayer is too long to type in this blog, but it can be found in any bencher, a book containing all of these prayers that is commonly distributed before this final prayer is recited.
While I have described the basic prayers and rituals surrounding each act of food consumption, I have not described my personal experience with these practices nor how they affect one's relationship to food and sustainability. Due to spacial constraints, I will keep this post and an introduction and continue to flesh out the concept of "giving thanks" in another entry.
On Shabbat, a family makes kiddush, or the blessing over the wine together. This prayer, in transliteration reads "Baruch atah Adonai Eloheinu melech ha-olam, borei p'ri hagafen," and in translation "Praised are you, the Lord our G-d, Sovereign of the universe, who creates the fruit of the vine" (B'kol Echad 9). The wine is then distributed among those at the table, often including a bit for the children or substituted with grape juice, and consumed. Although this practice does not occur every day of the week, it demonstrates an appreciation for this particular food. This practice also draws a loose connection between Judaism and Christianity, both of which have a special ceremonial place for wine, and reveals that alcohol is not only allowed in Judaism, but it an integral part of certain rituals.
The next sets of rituals apply on Shabbat and weekdays, with minor additions or alterations on Shabbat and other holidays.
![]() |
| Washing cup with two handles |
Next, a prayer is said over the bread called Ha-Motzi. Although one is supposed to be silent after washing, he or she can break this silence in order to make the bracha (singular of blessing) over the bread. Traditionally, two loaves of challah, the braided bread that women are commanded to make (and burn a piece of) for Shabbat, are lifted and someone says "Baruch atah Adonai, Eloheinu melech ha-olam, hamotzi lechem min ha-aretz," meaning, "Praised are You, Lord and G-d, Sovereign of the universe, who brings forth bread from the earth" (B'kol Echad 20). Those at the table then salt the bread in commemoration of the destruction of the Temple, break off a piece of bread, eat it themselves, and pass the loaf along to the next person. Then, the meal can proceed.
Finally, at the end of the meal, those who have dined recite Birkat Ha-Mazon, a prayer giving thanks to G-d for the food that was consumed, as well as giving thanks to G-d for the Torah and its teachings, exodus from Egypt, the land of Zion, and more. The prayer is too long to type in this blog, but it can be found in any bencher, a book containing all of these prayers that is commonly distributed before this final prayer is recited.
While I have described the basic prayers and rituals surrounding each act of food consumption, I have not described my personal experience with these practices nor how they affect one's relationship to food and sustainability. Due to spacial constraints, I will keep this post and an introduction and continue to flesh out the concept of "giving thanks" in another entry.
Why Kosher?
Because it is relatively a-typical to start keeping kosher in college, many people, Jews and non-Jews alike, have asked me why I made this choice. I grew up in a family with one sister who turned vegetarian and then vegan, so I modeled myself after her practice and thought of a variety of answers. While my response changes depending on my mood, my desire to explain myself to any one person, and my evolving relationship to keeping kosher, all of the following reasons constitute legitimate answers to the question: Why kosher?
1) Because the Torah Says So:
While this response runs contrary to the individualistic, self-governed approach to religion that is common in America today, especially among students at liberal universities such as Brown, the religious obligation to keep kosher is a main factor in my practice. The rules of kashrut were established in the Hebrew bible and by rabbinical thinkers, and it does not make sense to me to divorce this practice from its religious and historical Jewish roots. Still, I recognize that other biblical obligations have been disregarded throughout history in order to adapt Judaism to various times and locations.
Although religious reasons shape much of my decision, it is important to acknowledge that many religious Jews do not follow these rules. I was initially raised in a Reform Jewish environment where kashrut was not a concept I had encountered extensively. As one of the more liberal denominations in Judaism, the Reform movement in America has historically altered or disregarded aspects of Jewish observance in favor of easier, more Americanized religiosity. From colonial times until the twentieth century, obtaining kosher meat in this country, which lacked any religious authority figures until 1840, was incredibly difficult, time consuming, and expensive. Even today, dishonest business practices and price hikes plague the kosher meat industry. As a result, maintaining the laws of kashrut did not retain a central place in non-traditional Judaism. Still, there have always been Jews who struggled and succeeded in keeping kosher, and their market presence has led to organizations that investigate and mark kosher products, making approved food easier to find.
2) As a Way to Connect with the Jewish Community:
When I came to college, my relationship to the Jewish community changed substantially, and this is the main reason I started keeping kosher at this time. In fact, this is the main reason that the idea of keeping kosher even became a blip on my radar. As a child, I remember wanting to eat pepperoni pizza at a friend's house and not understanding why they would not allow me to do so; I know now that they kept kosher, but at the time this concept was foreign to me. Once I came to Brown and made friends at the Hillel house, kashrut became a subject of conversations with friends, learning sessions with the rabbi, and eating habits within the building. Learning about kashrut meant exploring thoughts and family histories of my Jewish peers. I was able to ask questions about their childhoods as well as their thoughts and feelings about Jewish observance as they transitioned from home to college. This topic served as a mechanism to bring me closer to my fellow Jewish students. My feelings of connection to other Jews extends beyond my Brown bubble to the greater Jewish community that exists both in this country and world-wide, although on a daily basis, I feel the bond with my immediate community in a much more prevalent way.
3) A Three-Times Daily Reminder of my Faith
In addition to observing kashrut, I began to observe many other Jewish customs, both religious and cultural. Still, holidays each come only one time per year, and while Shabbat comes each week, its obligations to suspend productive work are incredibly difficult to observe in a demanding college environment. Thus, keeping kosher served as the most frequent and most accessible reminder of my faith.
4) Mindful Eating
Besides being more conscious of what products I buy at the supermarket, keeping kosher generally makes me more mindful of what I eat. I have to consider what I am putting into my body, what ingredients go into my food, and how it is prepared. I also must notice the times I consume particular products. In all, this creates a much more thoughtful relationship to my food.
5) Health Benefits
Because I essentially keep vegetarian on every day but Shabbat, when Hillel provides dinner and lunch with kosher meat, I experience health benefits to keeping kosher. Meat, while it contains protein, is also often fatty, hormone-filled, and sometimes filled with bad bacteria. While I have been sick after eating a bad hot dog in the dining hall, a vegan pup (while not the tastiest) has never had a similar effect on my body. Due to the separation of milk and meat, I have also learned to create variety in my diet and include an array of nutrient-rich foods.
6) Theoretically Improved Treatment of Animals and Crops
Although there have been controversies recently about the treatment of workers and animals in the kosher meat industry, kosher food is theoretically supposed to be produced ethically. The foundations of ritual slaughter are based on raising and killing a healthy animal in the least painful way possible. This is why the act of killing is supposed to happen with one clean cut that kills the animal quickly. In addition, in order for meat to be considered glatt kosher (a strict kosher certification) the insides are inspected and must be free from disease and abnormalities. In theory, if not always in practice, kosher meat should be safer and its production should be more mindful of quality of life concerns for the animal.
Crops are also addressed in traditional literature concerning kashrut. Rules concerning the treatment of the land are intertwined with biblical passages about kosher meat. For example, there are rules governing what portions of the field can be used for their owner's consumption, which belonged to the government, and which must be left for charity. There are also regulations about how long a tree must bear fruit undisturbed before a person can harvest it for their own use. Finally, every seventh year the land is supposed to rest, paralleling the obligation for humans to rest every seventh day of the week. The respect that should conceivably been shown for the land and its produce creates a relationship in which humans are caring and grateful participants in their ecosystem.
(A quick note that there is now an ethical kosher movement to investigate and certify food producers that do truly follow the spirit of these laws and treat their animals and crops with respect).
7) To Honor My Grandfather's Memory
Last, but not least, is my sense of obligation to honor my grandfather's memory. My grandpa, Lenny, kept kosher as a child and even into adulthood, but he transitioned from Orthodox practices to Reform ones in order to make Jewish life more practical for his children. Always a kind and calm man, I never heard him complain about this shift. My commitment to expand my Jewish practice and knowledge is always related in part to the importance of religion in his life, which he sought to instill (though never forcefully) in his family.
1) Because the Torah Says So:
While this response runs contrary to the individualistic, self-governed approach to religion that is common in America today, especially among students at liberal universities such as Brown, the religious obligation to keep kosher is a main factor in my practice. The rules of kashrut were established in the Hebrew bible and by rabbinical thinkers, and it does not make sense to me to divorce this practice from its religious and historical Jewish roots. Still, I recognize that other biblical obligations have been disregarded throughout history in order to adapt Judaism to various times and locations.
Although religious reasons shape much of my decision, it is important to acknowledge that many religious Jews do not follow these rules. I was initially raised in a Reform Jewish environment where kashrut was not a concept I had encountered extensively. As one of the more liberal denominations in Judaism, the Reform movement in America has historically altered or disregarded aspects of Jewish observance in favor of easier, more Americanized religiosity. From colonial times until the twentieth century, obtaining kosher meat in this country, which lacked any religious authority figures until 1840, was incredibly difficult, time consuming, and expensive. Even today, dishonest business practices and price hikes plague the kosher meat industry. As a result, maintaining the laws of kashrut did not retain a central place in non-traditional Judaism. Still, there have always been Jews who struggled and succeeded in keeping kosher, and their market presence has led to organizations that investigate and mark kosher products, making approved food easier to find.
2) As a Way to Connect with the Jewish Community:
When I came to college, my relationship to the Jewish community changed substantially, and this is the main reason I started keeping kosher at this time. In fact, this is the main reason that the idea of keeping kosher even became a blip on my radar. As a child, I remember wanting to eat pepperoni pizza at a friend's house and not understanding why they would not allow me to do so; I know now that they kept kosher, but at the time this concept was foreign to me. Once I came to Brown and made friends at the Hillel house, kashrut became a subject of conversations with friends, learning sessions with the rabbi, and eating habits within the building. Learning about kashrut meant exploring thoughts and family histories of my Jewish peers. I was able to ask questions about their childhoods as well as their thoughts and feelings about Jewish observance as they transitioned from home to college. This topic served as a mechanism to bring me closer to my fellow Jewish students. My feelings of connection to other Jews extends beyond my Brown bubble to the greater Jewish community that exists both in this country and world-wide, although on a daily basis, I feel the bond with my immediate community in a much more prevalent way.
3) A Three-Times Daily Reminder of my Faith
In addition to observing kashrut, I began to observe many other Jewish customs, both religious and cultural. Still, holidays each come only one time per year, and while Shabbat comes each week, its obligations to suspend productive work are incredibly difficult to observe in a demanding college environment. Thus, keeping kosher served as the most frequent and most accessible reminder of my faith.
4) Mindful Eating
Besides being more conscious of what products I buy at the supermarket, keeping kosher generally makes me more mindful of what I eat. I have to consider what I am putting into my body, what ingredients go into my food, and how it is prepared. I also must notice the times I consume particular products. In all, this creates a much more thoughtful relationship to my food.
5) Health Benefits
Because I essentially keep vegetarian on every day but Shabbat, when Hillel provides dinner and lunch with kosher meat, I experience health benefits to keeping kosher. Meat, while it contains protein, is also often fatty, hormone-filled, and sometimes filled with bad bacteria. While I have been sick after eating a bad hot dog in the dining hall, a vegan pup (while not the tastiest) has never had a similar effect on my body. Due to the separation of milk and meat, I have also learned to create variety in my diet and include an array of nutrient-rich foods.
6) Theoretically Improved Treatment of Animals and Crops
Although there have been controversies recently about the treatment of workers and animals in the kosher meat industry, kosher food is theoretically supposed to be produced ethically. The foundations of ritual slaughter are based on raising and killing a healthy animal in the least painful way possible. This is why the act of killing is supposed to happen with one clean cut that kills the animal quickly. In addition, in order for meat to be considered glatt kosher (a strict kosher certification) the insides are inspected and must be free from disease and abnormalities. In theory, if not always in practice, kosher meat should be safer and its production should be more mindful of quality of life concerns for the animal.
Crops are also addressed in traditional literature concerning kashrut. Rules concerning the treatment of the land are intertwined with biblical passages about kosher meat. For example, there are rules governing what portions of the field can be used for their owner's consumption, which belonged to the government, and which must be left for charity. There are also regulations about how long a tree must bear fruit undisturbed before a person can harvest it for their own use. Finally, every seventh year the land is supposed to rest, paralleling the obligation for humans to rest every seventh day of the week. The respect that should conceivably been shown for the land and its produce creates a relationship in which humans are caring and grateful participants in their ecosystem.
(A quick note that there is now an ethical kosher movement to investigate and certify food producers that do truly follow the spirit of these laws and treat their animals and crops with respect).
7) To Honor My Grandfather's Memory
Last, but not least, is my sense of obligation to honor my grandfather's memory. My grandpa, Lenny, kept kosher as a child and even into adulthood, but he transitioned from Orthodox practices to Reform ones in order to make Jewish life more practical for his children. Always a kind and calm man, I never heard him complain about this shift. My commitment to expand my Jewish practice and knowledge is always related in part to the importance of religion in his life, which he sought to instill (though never forcefully) in his family.
Monday, February 20, 2012
Kosher in the Kitchen
After learning more extensively about the laws of kashrut and their origins, I had to determine how to apply these rules to my own habits. Because I had many friends within the active Jewish community at school, I decided to ask them about their particular habits. The vast majority would not eat un-kosher meat, but would eat dairy products and non-prohibited fish that were not kosher. Some people were on the school's kosher meal plan, so they kept to strictly kosher food when there were good options available, but on days with unappetizing food, they would simply eat vegetarian in the regular dining hall. Still others said that within their homes they kept strictly kosher and would not eat anything without a heckscher, but would simply not eat meat outside of their home. I decided that, because I had already paid for the regular meal plan at school, and because I did not have a kitchen of my own, I would not eat meat in the dining halls, but I would eat all other foods that were non-heckschered, provided that they were not prohibited (such as shellfish).
Initially with the rabbi's help (he is a great cook who has his own kosher food blog) I began cooking. We made butternut squash soup, pastas, and salads. Importantly, he also taught me about traditional Jewish foods. I learned how to make falafel, couscous, roasted chickpeas, baba ghanoush, and other Mediterranean foods, as well as traditional Ashkenazi (German Jewish) ones such as matzoh ball soup and schnitzel. I also made food for specific holidays; hamentashen for Purim, latkes for Hanukkah, macaroons for Pesach, and apple and honey cake for Rosh Hashanah. I also braided challah each week with a friend before Shabbat started; baking this bread and burning a piece of the loaf in commemoration of the destruction of the temple is one of a Jewish woman's only positive, time-sensitive commandments. Thus, my eating habits were expanding not only my palate, but also my knowledge of the Jewish traditions, calendar, religion, and culture. As I munched on all of these delicious new foods, the list of reasons why I enjoyed keeping kosher expanded. I will explore my reasons for keeping these restrictions, both intentional and discovered, in my next post.
I had set my own guidelines and began to follow them; this change led me to expand my diet greatly because I had to try new vegetarian food to get vitamins and protein I had previously received from eating meat. I tried tacos with refried beans rather than meat, and it turned out that this lumpy brown food that I had previously judged based on looks alone was incredibly tasty. I also learned to love almonds, walnuts, onions, chickpeas, spinach, avocado, pears, cranberries, soy substitutes, green peppers, and more. Some of these foods I grew to like because they were commonly ingredients in the vegetarian options at the dining halls; others I had avoided irrationally as a child, and keeping kosher pushed me to expand my palate. Once I was changing my eating habits to begin with, I became much more open to trying (and re-trying) various foods.
While this focus on consumption was important, I also wanted to learn how to produce kosher food. Because I could not find time to learn how to make kosher cheese or meat (and I preferred reading about kosher slaughter to the thought of participating myself), I considered learning how to cook a sufficient form of production. I already knew how to make meals and bake desserts; when my parents divorced, I had to learn how to make food in order to avoid eating Chinese food or pizza every time I visited my father. Because I started making full dinners at age twelve, I assumed learning how to cook kosher food would be relatively simple...I was wrong. I started this process at home and realized that most of my recipes included both meat and dairy, or I would bake a dairy dessert to eat after a chicken meal, forgetting that I had to wait three hours to eat that food. After a couple of stare-downs with cookies and cakes, I decided to get serious about this part of my kosher experience.
When I returned to school after a winter break full of misguided culinary experiments, I asked the rabbi at Hillel to teach me how to use the kosher kitchen in the building. He took me into the kitchen and explained that the room had a meat side and a dairy side. Each had its own refrigerator and oven, but there was only one stove, which was located on the meat side but could be used for either product as long as the utensils were not put down on the nearby meat table if I was using the range to cook a dairy dish. There were also separate freezers, but I was told that technically, as long as they were wrapped, meat and diary food could go into the same fridge or freezer, and that this kitchen had separate ones mostly for increased space. He also showed me the different sets of cooking utensils, mixing bowls, peelers, knives, and dining ware for each side. Luckily, everything was labeled with a sticker that indicated which side it belonged to; red for meat, blue for dairy. Furthermore, I could only bring food into the kitchen that was strictly kosher, meaning it had a heckscher mark or it was fresh produce without any bugs (unfortunately, organic produce proved tricky because it generally has small bugs). Due to this particular restriction, I learned how to shop for kosher products at the grocery store, recognizing approved heckschers and where to find them on packaging. The rules were tricky, and specific incidents raised specific questions, but, armed with the rabbi's cell phone number for questions or concerns, I managed all-right. Most importantly, he assured me that it is incredible difficult to mess up a kosher kitchen entirely, and that most mistakes could be solved with a boiling pot of water, which is used to re-kasher items that have touched the wrong ingredients.
![]() |
| Taboule salad (right) and purple cabbage dish I actually made with the rabbi (image courtesy of frumfoodie.com) |
Biblical and Rabbinical Foundations
While my personal story may be fun to tell, it is also important to explore the roots of kashrut; to be honest, this explanation was part of my "kosher education," because I wanted to learn the origins of the practice I was now determined to follow.
The laws of kashrut, as I expressed in a previous post about all of my new "cants" is based on prohibitions. These prohibitions are broken down into the categories biblical and rabbinical, the first coming from holy text, the latter from learned men in a later era. Because many Jews believe the bible to be the word of G-d, biblical prohibitions are especially important to follow, and back when Jews were policed by their own community, breaking a biblical prohibition carried a harsher punishment.
Biblical prohibitions and their meanings:
-Non-kosher land animals are defined in Leviticus 11:3-8, where Moses and Aaron are commanded to tell the Israelites, "These are the creatures that you may eat from among all the land animals: any animal that has true hoofs, with clefts through the hoofs, and that chews the cud--such you may eat" (JPS Tanakh 228). This passage goes on to clarify that neither the camel, nor the daman (a type of rodent), hare, nor swine are acceptable because either they chew their cud or have a cloven hoof, but the combination is necessary for an animal to be considered kosher. This message is also echoed in Deuteronomy 14: 3-8.
-Non-kosher swimming and flying animals are defined in Deuteronomy 14: 9-18, "These you may eat of all that live in water: you may eat anything that has fins and scales. But you may not eat anything that had no fins and scales: it is unclean for you. You may eat any clean bird. The following you may not eat: the eagle, the vulture, and the black vulture; the kite, the falcon, and the buzzard..." (JPS Tanakh 406-7). The list goes on to state that bats, pelicans, storks, and more may not be eaten.
-Finally, in Deuteronomy 14: 21 is the statement "You shall not boil a kid in its mother's milk" (JPS Tanakh 407), leading to the separation of all meat from all dairy products today.
Okay, so these biblical prohibitions may cover a variety of creatures, but I do not want to eat bats, vultures, camels, or rodents anyway. In order to define these prohibitions and debate and define gray areas, rabbinical rules were established as well. Rabbinical prohibitions, which added onto biblical ones to create a more extensive set of rules also served the purpose of further segregating the Jewish community from their non-Jewish neighbors.
Rabbinically prohibited foods include:
-Non-Kosher milk or cheese, which means the product must come from a kosher animal and not be mixed with the milk of a non-kosher one
-Non-Kosher wine, which then meant wine that was produced for idolatrous purposes
-Foods or combinations of food that are considered health risks (as scientific knowledge increased and became integrated in contemporary times, thoughts about health risks from food change)
-Food cooked by a non-Jew; this was primarily targeted at reducing intermarriage, which was originally uncommon, but still possible during most generations
-There is also a condition, that there should be a tradition (masorah) for a food to be eaten, meaning that turkey, which was not present throughout much of Jewish history but became popular in America, posed a tricky situation.
These rules explained why I could order lobster, shrimp, ham, cheeseburgers, or those much sought-after delicacies like bat, pelican, and camel (yuck!). But, as tempted as I was to order a milkshake with a side of rodent, I still needed to determine how to adopt these rules into my observance of kashrut. Should I eat turkey? What about food cooked by non-Jews? Or non-Kosher cheese? I will explore my methods of teasing these rules out in my personal practice in the next post.
The laws of kashrut, as I expressed in a previous post about all of my new "cants" is based on prohibitions. These prohibitions are broken down into the categories biblical and rabbinical, the first coming from holy text, the latter from learned men in a later era. Because many Jews believe the bible to be the word of G-d, biblical prohibitions are especially important to follow, and back when Jews were policed by their own community, breaking a biblical prohibition carried a harsher punishment.
Biblical prohibitions and their meanings:
![]() |
| A pretty handy book. |
-Non-kosher swimming and flying animals are defined in Deuteronomy 14: 9-18, "These you may eat of all that live in water: you may eat anything that has fins and scales. But you may not eat anything that had no fins and scales: it is unclean for you. You may eat any clean bird. The following you may not eat: the eagle, the vulture, and the black vulture; the kite, the falcon, and the buzzard..." (JPS Tanakh 406-7). The list goes on to state that bats, pelicans, storks, and more may not be eaten.
-Finally, in Deuteronomy 14: 21 is the statement "You shall not boil a kid in its mother's milk" (JPS Tanakh 407), leading to the separation of all meat from all dairy products today.
Okay, so these biblical prohibitions may cover a variety of creatures, but I do not want to eat bats, vultures, camels, or rodents anyway. In order to define these prohibitions and debate and define gray areas, rabbinical rules were established as well. Rabbinical prohibitions, which added onto biblical ones to create a more extensive set of rules also served the purpose of further segregating the Jewish community from their non-Jewish neighbors.
Rabbinically prohibited foods include:
-Non-Kosher milk or cheese, which means the product must come from a kosher animal and not be mixed with the milk of a non-kosher one
-Non-Kosher wine, which then meant wine that was produced for idolatrous purposes
-Foods or combinations of food that are considered health risks (as scientific knowledge increased and became integrated in contemporary times, thoughts about health risks from food change)
-Food cooked by a non-Jew; this was primarily targeted at reducing intermarriage, which was originally uncommon, but still possible during most generations
-There is also a condition, that there should be a tradition (masorah) for a food to be eaten, meaning that turkey, which was not present throughout much of Jewish history but became popular in America, posed a tricky situation.
These rules explained why I could order lobster, shrimp, ham, cheeseburgers, or those much sought-after delicacies like bat, pelican, and camel (yuck!). But, as tempted as I was to order a milkshake with a side of rodent, I still needed to determine how to adopt these rules into my observance of kashrut. Should I eat turkey? What about food cooked by non-Jews? Or non-Kosher cheese? I will explore my methods of teasing these rules out in my personal practice in the next post.
Thursday, February 16, 2012
Stylishly Kosher
After learning a bit about the laws of kashrut and deciding to implement these rules on my own eating habits, I started a gradual transition toward keeping kosher. First, I ate "kosher style," which can be defined in a variety of ways, but to me meant not eating any categorically forbidden animal (pork or shellfish), and separating dairy and meat. I separated dairy and meat temporally, initially waiting thirty minutes after eating dairy before consuming meat, and one hour in the other direction. I planned to increase the amount of time between meat and dairy as I practiced this new eating style to the more common three hour wait.
I started with this separation for several reasons. First, with the exception of bacon, I did not enjoy eating any categorically forbidden animals in the first place. Second, the only biblical passage directly related to these dietary laws is Deuteronomy 14:21 "Do not cook a young goat in its mother's milk." While laws concerning the interpretation and implementation of this passage expanded over the centuries, I interpreted this call for the separation of milk and meat as a legitimate starting point for my transition.
Because I started eating "kosher style" at Brown University, I was faced with the challenge of picking through my options at the dining hall to find foods I considered suitable. Because I did not want to simply eat vegetarian and consider every meal a dairy one, I initially came up with creative excuses to eat the foods I wanted. I would start my meal with soft serve or a cookie, wait a half an hour, and then eat salad topped with chicken; after all, my Nana always taught me that life is unpredictable, so dessert really should be eaten first. Or, I would follow the great Talmudic commentator Rashi's alleged dietary habits and I wouldn't count chicken as meat, so I could eat that creamy cajun chicken pasta. More often than not, though, I would fudge the time between my meat and milk, telling myself it was okay to get hot chocolate thirty-five minutes after my burger because it was winter, and I had waited a bit anyway.
One day this lame pattern of inconsistencies changed; I had just re-read Night, Elie Wiesel's famous memoir about the Holocaust, which I knew almost by heart, when a new doubt stirred within me. How could a greater power, G-d, allow this to have happened? While this is not a new struggle for Jews, or people more generally, this level of anger and doubt was new to me. In a childish act of defiance, I ate a bacon blue cheese burger. I was expecting this old favorite to taste good, but I was repulsed after my first bite. I had heard that Jews who kept kosher sometimes disliked the smell of bacon or the sight of treifa (un-kosher) food, but I always assumed this is a lie they bought into because they secretly wanted to know how great this food tastes. But I was sharing this feeling, and to me it symbolized both my growing connection to the Jewish community and my need to put more effort into keeping kosher.
I wont tell you that from that moment on I never ate dairy or meat before I should have, or that my mouth didn't still water at the smell of bacon, but when I did slip up, it was by mistake, and I genuinely tried to keep my commitment to maintaining my kosher-ish habits. This would prove to be only the first step in my path to become better educated, more observant, and increasingly connected, through food, to my faith.
![]() |
| At a kosher McDonald's, they have separate kitchens for milkshakes and burgers |
Because I started eating "kosher style" at Brown University, I was faced with the challenge of picking through my options at the dining hall to find foods I considered suitable. Because I did not want to simply eat vegetarian and consider every meal a dairy one, I initially came up with creative excuses to eat the foods I wanted. I would start my meal with soft serve or a cookie, wait a half an hour, and then eat salad topped with chicken; after all, my Nana always taught me that life is unpredictable, so dessert really should be eaten first. Or, I would follow the great Talmudic commentator Rashi's alleged dietary habits and I wouldn't count chicken as meat, so I could eat that creamy cajun chicken pasta. More often than not, though, I would fudge the time between my meat and milk, telling myself it was okay to get hot chocolate thirty-five minutes after my burger because it was winter, and I had waited a bit anyway.
One day this lame pattern of inconsistencies changed; I had just re-read Night, Elie Wiesel's famous memoir about the Holocaust, which I knew almost by heart, when a new doubt stirred within me. How could a greater power, G-d, allow this to have happened? While this is not a new struggle for Jews, or people more generally, this level of anger and doubt was new to me. In a childish act of defiance, I ate a bacon blue cheese burger. I was expecting this old favorite to taste good, but I was repulsed after my first bite. I had heard that Jews who kept kosher sometimes disliked the smell of bacon or the sight of treifa (un-kosher) food, but I always assumed this is a lie they bought into because they secretly wanted to know how great this food tastes. But I was sharing this feeling, and to me it symbolized both my growing connection to the Jewish community and my need to put more effort into keeping kosher.
I wont tell you that from that moment on I never ate dairy or meat before I should have, or that my mouth didn't still water at the smell of bacon, but when I did slip up, it was by mistake, and I genuinely tried to keep my commitment to maintaining my kosher-ish habits. This would prove to be only the first step in my path to become better educated, more observant, and increasingly connected, through food, to my faith.
Wednesday, February 15, 2012
Introduction
Hello and thanks for reading kosher@kollege! I am a sophomore at Brown University who started keeping kosher in college. I am in a class called Sustenance and Sustainability, and for our quarter term project, we can write a paper and/or a blog about religion and food. Because I write papers all the time (oh humanities classes!) and blogging is pretty new to me (I am technologically impaired), I figured I would widen my horizons a bit.
Anyway, for those who may not know, keeping kosher means maintaining certain dietary practices and restrictions. Some basic ones are:
-Do not mix dairy and meat products (cheeseburgers are out of the question)
-No pork or shellfish (bacon-wrapped shrimp, also not okay)
-Only eat animals with a split hoof (cows-thumbs up, pigs-thumbs down)
-Do not eat non-kosher meat (there is a specific way to slaughter an animal that must be followed)
There are also a whole set of rule about how long one should wait between eating milk (dairy) and meat, and vice versa. Most people wait either no time or a half an hour between milk and meat, and three to six hours between meat and milk, because the fat/particles stay in your mouth longer. This is the basic information that I began my eating-style change with, but I will expand upon it as my story unfolds.
Essentially, keeping the laws of kashrut (kosher) sounds like a bunch of "cants." I can't enjoy my beloved bacon blue cheese burgers anymore, I can't have chicken Parmesan, and even marshmallows, which are often made with pig gelatin, are out of the question. So, why would I want to impose such restrictions on myself when I just started to enjoy the freedom of college? I do not come from a religious household; in fact, while both of my biological parents are Jewish, my mother's partner, Lisa, is Italian Catholic. I went to an after-school program at a synagogue and was Bat Mitzvahed, but after that I joined a Unitarian Universalist Fellowship. My story is far from typical, but I will try to explain.
When I arrived a Brown, two upper class men knocked on my door and invited me to a BBQ at Hillel, the center for Jewish life on campus. I didn't know how they found me, because I had marked my religion as "Unitarian" on my application, even though I was very unsure where I stood religiously. Still, I was not one to turn down a free burger, so I went to the event. I was impressed by how welcoming everyone was, and I decided to come back for various events throughout the week...and I essentially never left. If you ask anyone today where I am, they will probably direct you toward Hillel.
As I became more secure in the community, I began learning with the rabbi here. I had so many questions about Shabbat, weddings, LGBTQ issues, literature, history, and, yes, kashrut. The rabbi patiently answered my questions, but I realized that my learning would have to be experiential. I fiddled with different observances and rituals, but the one that always seemed the most foreign to me was keeping kosher. Rather than stay within my comfort zone and keep my Jewish education on the periphery, I decided to put it front and center; it would affect my thinking three times each day, minimum.
That was my rather rash decision, and this blog will track the story of my clumsy, disorganized path toward kosher eating, as well as the breadth of knowledge I came to uncover as a result of this choice.
-Do not mix dairy and meat products (cheeseburgers are out of the question)-No pork or shellfish (bacon-wrapped shrimp, also not okay)
-Only eat animals with a split hoof (cows-thumbs up, pigs-thumbs down)
-Do not eat non-kosher meat (there is a specific way to slaughter an animal that must be followed)
There are also a whole set of rule about how long one should wait between eating milk (dairy) and meat, and vice versa. Most people wait either no time or a half an hour between milk and meat, and three to six hours between meat and milk, because the fat/particles stay in your mouth longer. This is the basic information that I began my eating-style change with, but I will expand upon it as my story unfolds.
Essentially, keeping the laws of kashrut (kosher) sounds like a bunch of "cants." I can't enjoy my beloved bacon blue cheese burgers anymore, I can't have chicken Parmesan, and even marshmallows, which are often made with pig gelatin, are out of the question. So, why would I want to impose such restrictions on myself when I just started to enjoy the freedom of college? I do not come from a religious household; in fact, while both of my biological parents are Jewish, my mother's partner, Lisa, is Italian Catholic. I went to an after-school program at a synagogue and was Bat Mitzvahed, but after that I joined a Unitarian Universalist Fellowship. My story is far from typical, but I will try to explain.
When I arrived a Brown, two upper class men knocked on my door and invited me to a BBQ at Hillel, the center for Jewish life on campus. I didn't know how they found me, because I had marked my religion as "Unitarian" on my application, even though I was very unsure where I stood religiously. Still, I was not one to turn down a free burger, so I went to the event. I was impressed by how welcoming everyone was, and I decided to come back for various events throughout the week...and I essentially never left. If you ask anyone today where I am, they will probably direct you toward Hillel.As I became more secure in the community, I began learning with the rabbi here. I had so many questions about Shabbat, weddings, LGBTQ issues, literature, history, and, yes, kashrut. The rabbi patiently answered my questions, but I realized that my learning would have to be experiential. I fiddled with different observances and rituals, but the one that always seemed the most foreign to me was keeping kosher. Rather than stay within my comfort zone and keep my Jewish education on the periphery, I decided to put it front and center; it would affect my thinking three times each day, minimum.
That was my rather rash decision, and this blog will track the story of my clumsy, disorganized path toward kosher eating, as well as the breadth of knowledge I came to uncover as a result of this choice.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




