Because it is relatively a-typical to start keeping kosher in college, many people, Jews and non-Jews alike, have asked me why I made this choice. I grew up in a family with one sister who turned vegetarian and then vegan, so I modeled myself after her practice and thought of a variety of answers. While my response changes depending on my mood, my desire to explain myself to any one person, and my evolving relationship to keeping kosher, all of the following reasons constitute legitimate answers to the question: Why kosher?
1) Because the Torah Says So:
While this response runs contrary to the individualistic, self-governed approach to religion that is common in America today, especially among students at liberal universities such as Brown, the religious obligation to keep kosher is a main factor in my practice. The rules of kashrut were established in the Hebrew bible and by rabbinical thinkers, and it does not make sense to me to divorce this practice from its religious and historical Jewish roots. Still, I recognize that other biblical obligations have been disregarded throughout history in order to adapt Judaism to various times and locations.
Although religious reasons shape much of my decision, it is important to acknowledge that many religious Jews do not follow these rules. I was initially raised in a Reform Jewish environment where kashrut was not a concept I had encountered extensively. As one of the more liberal denominations in Judaism, the Reform movement in America has historically altered or disregarded aspects of Jewish observance in favor of easier, more Americanized religiosity. From colonial times until the twentieth century, obtaining kosher meat in this country, which lacked any religious authority figures until 1840, was incredibly difficult, time consuming, and expensive. Even today, dishonest business practices and price hikes plague the kosher meat industry. As a result, maintaining the laws of kashrut did not retain a central place in non-traditional Judaism. Still, there have always been Jews who struggled and succeeded in keeping kosher, and their market presence has led to organizations that investigate and mark kosher products, making approved food easier to find.
2) As a Way to Connect with the Jewish Community:
When I came to college, my relationship to the Jewish community changed substantially, and this is the main reason I started keeping kosher at this time. In fact, this is the main reason that the idea of keeping kosher even became a blip on my radar. As a child, I remember wanting to eat pepperoni pizza at a friend's house and not understanding why they would not allow me to do so; I know now that they kept kosher, but at the time this concept was foreign to me. Once I came to Brown and made friends at the Hillel house, kashrut became a subject of conversations with friends, learning sessions with the rabbi, and eating habits within the building. Learning about kashrut meant exploring thoughts and family histories of my Jewish peers. I was able to ask questions about their childhoods as well as their thoughts and feelings about Jewish observance as they transitioned from home to college. This topic served as a mechanism to bring me closer to my fellow Jewish students. My feelings of connection to other Jews extends beyond my Brown bubble to the greater Jewish community that exists both in this country and world-wide, although on a daily basis, I feel the bond with my immediate community in a much more prevalent way.
3) A Three-Times Daily Reminder of my Faith
In addition to observing kashrut, I began to observe many other Jewish customs, both religious and cultural. Still, holidays each come only one time per year, and while Shabbat comes each week, its obligations to suspend productive work are incredibly difficult to observe in a demanding college environment. Thus, keeping kosher served as the most frequent and most accessible reminder of my faith.
4) Mindful Eating
Besides being more conscious of what products I buy at the supermarket, keeping kosher generally makes me more mindful of what I eat. I have to consider what I am putting into my body, what ingredients go into my food, and how it is prepared. I also must notice the times I consume particular products. In all, this creates a much more thoughtful relationship to my food.
5) Health Benefits
Because I essentially keep vegetarian on every day but Shabbat, when Hillel provides dinner and lunch with kosher meat, I experience health benefits to keeping kosher. Meat, while it contains protein, is also often fatty, hormone-filled, and sometimes filled with bad bacteria. While I have been sick after eating a bad hot dog in the dining hall, a vegan pup (while not the tastiest) has never had a similar effect on my body. Due to the separation of milk and meat, I have also learned to create variety in my diet and include an array of nutrient-rich foods.
6) Theoretically Improved Treatment of Animals and Crops
Although there have been controversies recently about the treatment of workers and animals in the kosher meat industry, kosher food is theoretically supposed to be produced ethically. The foundations of ritual slaughter are based on raising and killing a healthy animal in the least painful way possible. This is why the act of killing is supposed to happen with one clean cut that kills the animal quickly. In addition, in order for meat to be considered glatt kosher (a strict kosher certification) the insides are inspected and must be free from disease and abnormalities. In theory, if not always in practice, kosher meat should be safer and its production should be more mindful of quality of life concerns for the animal.
Crops are also addressed in traditional literature concerning kashrut. Rules concerning the treatment of the land are intertwined with biblical passages about kosher meat. For example, there are rules governing what portions of the field can be used for their owner's consumption, which belonged to the government, and which must be left for charity. There are also regulations about how long a tree must bear fruit undisturbed before a person can harvest it for their own use. Finally, every seventh year the land is supposed to rest, paralleling the obligation for humans to rest every seventh day of the week. The respect that should conceivably been shown for the land and its produce creates a relationship in which humans are caring and grateful participants in their ecosystem.
(A quick note that there is now an ethical kosher movement to investigate and certify food producers that do truly follow the spirit of these laws and treat their animals and crops with respect).
7) To Honor My Grandfather's Memory
Last, but not least, is my sense of obligation to honor my grandfather's memory. My grandpa, Lenny, kept kosher as a child and even into adulthood, but he transitioned from Orthodox practices to Reform ones in order to make Jewish life more practical for his children. Always a kind and calm man, I never heard him complain about this shift. My commitment to expand my Jewish practice and knowledge is always related in part to the importance of religion in his life, which he sought to instill (though never forcefully) in his family.
No comments:
Post a Comment